Post Time: 2025-09-01
Why Your A1c May Be INCORRECT! Your Doc May Not Even Know!
The A1c test, also known as the glycated hemoglobin test, is a crucial tool used to monitor long-term blood sugar levels in individuals, especially those with diabetes. It provides an average of blood glucose levels over the past two to three months, offering a valuable glimpse into how well diabetes is being managed. However, what if the results you’re getting aren’t entirely accurate? Unfortunately, this is a possibility and it is crucial to know when your A1c results may not be correct, and why your doctor may not be aware of the factors influencing it. This article will delve into the factors that can skew A1c test results, explore some surprising elements that can render them inaccurate, and what you can do to ensure you get the most reliable picture of your average blood sugar levels.
What the A1c Actually Measures
Before we discuss the pitfalls, let's understand what the A1c test measures. This test assesses the amount of glucose attached to your hemoglobin molecules within your red blood cells. The more glucose there is in your bloodstream, the more glucose will attach to your hemoglobin. Because red blood cells have a lifespan of approximately three months, the A1c test can therefore reflect average blood glucose levels over that period. This is why the A1c is such a valuable tool for people managing diabetes and for screening for diabetes and prediabetes.
A1c: Reference Range
| Here are the typical A1c result interpretations: | A1c Level | Interpretation |
|---|---|---|
| Below 5.7% | Normal | |
| 5.7% to 6.4% | Prediabetes | |
| 6.5% or higher | Diabetes |
\ A crucial point is that each percentage point of A1c reflects an increase or decrease of approximately 30mg/dl in your average blood glucose. However, many factors can influence these readings, which can be cause for concern.
Factors That Can Falsely Elevate Your A1c Results
While a high A1c level typically points to poor blood sugar control, certain factors can artificially elevate your results without any increase in actual blood glucose:
-
Anemia:
- Iron-deficiency anemia can lead to a falsely high A1c.
- When red blood cells don’t contain enough iron, the lifespan of these cells can be affected. Younger red blood cells will contain more hemoglobin. As a result, more hemoglobin could become glycated, creating a misleadingly high result, even if your average blood sugar is well managed.
- Similarly, other conditions leading to abnormal red blood cell production, such as a B12 deficiency, could lead to similarly inaccurate results.
-
Kidney Disease:
- Kidney disease can cause uremia which can lead to higher A1c readings as it can interfere with the test. In fact, as kidney function declines, the likelihood of inaccurate results increases.
-
Certain Medications:
- Certain drugs, such as corticosteroids and some medications used for HIV, can lead to false A1c readings.
- In addition, some medications that can affect red blood cell turnover may also lead to A1c inaccuracies.
- In some cases, specific medications can influence the rate at which glucose binds to hemoglobin.
-
Alcohol Abuse
- Long term alcohol abuse can significantly alter blood glucose patterns, with both hyperglycemia (elevated blood glucose) and hypoglycemia (low blood glucose) occurring with or without a corresponding effect on A1c results.
- The changes related to chronic alcohol use on blood glucose levels and their relationship with A1c may affect the reliability of the results.
Factors That Can Falsely Lower Your A1c Results
Equally, some conditions can produce deceptively low A1c results, giving you the false impression that your blood sugar control is better than it is.
- Hemolytic Anemia:
- This is a condition in which red blood cells are destroyed faster than they are made. Because they are destroyed sooner, there is not a full 120 day exposure to glucose, causing a deceptively low A1c.
- Certain Vitamin Deficiencies
- Vitamin C deficiencies may also lead to falsely lower A1c results. Vitamin C is an essential cofactor for various enzymatic reactions involved in red blood cell health and glucose metabolism. Without sufficient Vitamin C, red blood cells may be less stable, thus reducing their average lifespan. This lower lifespan can then influence the reading of the A1c.
- Blood Loss
- If you recently experienced significant blood loss, you can have an artificially lowered A1c due to the loss of older blood cells that have been exposed to glucose longer. The remaining cells, on average, will be younger with less glycated hemoglobin, and your test results will therefore be unreliable.
- Pregnancy:
- During pregnancy, blood volume expands, and red blood cell turnover can be more rapid. As a result, A1c levels can appear lower than your true average blood sugar readings, making the results unreliable for screening or diagnostic purposes.
Why Your Doctor Might Not Know
It’s not that your doctor isn't knowledgeable, but there are several reasons why they may not be aware of the full scope of factors influencing A1c accuracy:
- Complexity of the Test:
- Many of the reasons for inaccurate A1c tests are highly specific and may not be encountered often by general practitioners. The test has a high specificity and sensitivity when the other factors discussed in this article are not a consideration. It is generally only when there are extenuating circumstances that these become of concern.
- Relying on Standard Protocols:
- Doctors may follow routine guidelines, which do not always account for individual patient variances, such as comorbidities or medication usage that can impact A1c results.
- Time Constraints:
- During short patient appointments, it is challenging to dive deeply into every specific medical condition or personal issue that might affect the A1c. Doctors must triage, and often time simply does not allow for a full review of all of these factors.
- Lack of Continuous Education:
- Medical science is constantly evolving, and not all clinicians are kept up to date on every detail that may affect laboratory test results. While a general understanding of the test exists, the specific factors that can contribute to inaccurate readings can be easily missed by even dedicated healthcare practitioners.
- Patient history:
- Some patients may not realize that they should report all of the factors that affect the validity of the A1c test, thus your doctor may not be aware of those elements.
What Can You Do?
If you have concerns about your A1c results, take these steps:
- Discuss with your doctor: Be upfront about any health conditions, medications, or other factors that may influence your A1c test. Your healthcare provider can decide to adjust the treatment plan in light of the test results.
- Multiple Glucose Monitoring Options
- Depending on your unique circumstances, alternative methods may be needed to better understand blood glucose fluctuations. One approach involves using continuous glucose monitoring (CGM). By providing data points around the clock, these technologies allow you to track your glucose levels over a longer period, highlighting trends and peaks and valleys that a single A1c test cannot reveal.
- Request a Blood Workup: Ask your physician to perform blood tests to rule out any other factor that may be influencing the A1c results, such as anemic conditions or kidney or liver disease. This may include a full blood cell count or a metabolic panel.
- Advocate for yourself: Ensure that your doctor is taking into consideration all of the conditions, medications, and lifestyles you have that could be impacting the accuracy of the A1c. It is important to have the most accurate assessment of your glucose levels to plan an effective treatment strategy.
- Regular Follow Up:
- When the condition and treatment options are not clear cut, it may be necessary to have more frequent follow-up appointments with your doctor. By engaging in regular communication with your doctor, both of you can evaluate glucose fluctuations over time to better tailor treatment to your specific needs.
Conclusion
While the A1c test is undoubtedly a vital tool for managing diabetes and monitoring glucose control, it's not without its limitations. A range of conditions, from anemia to medication use, can skew results, potentially leading to misguided treatment decisions. To avoid misinterpretations, be aware of these factors and openly communicate your circumstances with your doctor. Using CGM when appropriate and regular monitoring with your health care provider, are additional ways to improve your blood glucose management. Always question your results if you feel something doesn't make sense, and take an active role in managing your health for optimal outcomes.
Insulin IQ community member, Pam asks why using MCT oil, which is not an exogenous ketone, still raises her ketone levels. Dr. Bikman explains that MCTs and shorter fats are absorbed directly into the bloodstream from the gut, bypassing the complex process green tea for lowering blood sugar longer fats undergo. These fats go straight to the liver, which must immediately burn them due to what can you drink to lower blood sugar their short carbon chains, as cells cannot store such short-chain fats. This increased fat burning in the liver results in higher ketone production, making MCTs highly ketogenic. #MCTOil #Ketones #DrBenBikman #KetogenicDiet #Health #Nutrition #MetabolicHealth #KetoScience #FatBurning #KetoLife #KetoCommunity #HealthyLiving #LowCarb #Ketosis #KetoDiet #MCTBenefits #KetoLifestyle #NutritionScience #KetoFacts a1c 4.8 average blood sugar #HealthTips